This Fireside Pumpkin (renamed from just “Fireside” since we already had that one in the index) is the creation of Jason Asher, the mastermind behind the brilliant UnderTow tiki bar chain in Phoenix, Arizona. Jägermeister, a sweet Kräuterlikör, is one of our favorite offbeat ingredients to bring into a tropical cocktail, and here Asher uses its baking-spice flavors to great effect alongside pumpkin syrup and condensed milk. Despite the pie-flavored base, the drink stays light and tart and utterly drinkable, a testament to Asher’s alchemical talents.
